Catering Guide

Jersey Mike's Catering Menu

Tyler Brooks, Food & Menu Researcher · Last verified August 2026

Quick answer: Jersey Mike's catering comes in two main formats: individually boxed lunches (one sub, chips, and a cookie per person) and Subs by the Box, whole subs sliced into pieces for a group, essentially their version of a party tray. Both use the same fresh-sliced ingredients as an in-store order. Pricing and exact serving sizes vary enough by location that it's worth getting a direct quote rather than relying on a number you saw somewhere else.

Jersey Mike's catering party sub tray sliced into pieces for a group event

The Two Catering Formats

Almost everything on the catering menu falls into one of two categories, and picking the right one depends more on how your group actually eats than on price alone.

Boxed Lunches

One sub per person, individually packaged with chips and a cookie. Each box can hold a different sub, so people with different preferences (or allergies) aren't stuck with one shared option.

Best for: meetings, offices, anyone needing individual portions

Subs by the Box

Whole subs, sliced into pieces and arranged for sharing, effectively Jersey Mike's version of a party tray, even though the menu doesn't use that word. Usually offered across a handful of sub varieties per box, so a group can sample more than one flavor without everyone ordering separately.

Best for: parties, casual gatherings, groups who don't mind sharing

The practical difference comes down to logistics. Boxed lunches take longer to assemble since each one is packed separately, but they eliminate any confusion about who's eating what. Subs by the Box are faster to set out and serve, closer to what most people picture when they ask for a party tray, but work better for a casual event than a formal meeting where people want to eat at their desks.

What's Actually in Each Order

A boxed lunch includes your choice of sub, a bag of chips, and a cookie, made Mike's Way unless you specify otherwise. Drinks are typically sold separately rather than bundled in.

Subs by the Box typically lets you choose across several sub varieties, most commonly a mix of Italian-style, turkey and provolone, and club-style subs, though the exact selection can vary by location. Desserts (cookies or brownies) and drinks are usually available as separate add-ons rather than included by default, our Sides Menu and Drinks Menu pages cover what's typically on offer.

Hot subs for catering: catering menus commonly default to cold subs. Whether hot subs are available for your order isn't consistent across locations, confirm directly with your store if a hot sub is what your group actually wants.

Pricing and Serving Sizes: What Actually Determines Your Cost

Catering quotes for the same order type can swing by a wide margin depending on where you are and what's in season promotionally. A boxed lunch that runs one price at a location in one state can cost noticeably more or less at a different store, and the same is true for a full Subs by the Box order. Location, sub selection, and whatever promotion is active that week all move the number more than most published price lists account for. It's worth checking our current coupons and deals before you order, since a catering-eligible promotion can meaningfully change the total.

What stays consistent regardless of location: boxed lunches are priced per person, and Subs by the Box are priced per box rather than per person, that structural difference matters more for comparing the two formats than any specific dollar figure would. For the actual number, your local store or the official catering order page for your event date is the only source that reflects what you'll really pay. Confirming your store's hours and location details ahead of time also helps, since catering pickup windows don't always match regular counter hours.

Jersey Mike's boxed lunch catering with sub, chips, and cookie

A standard boxed lunch: sub, chips, and a cookie, individually packaged.

How to Order, Step by Step

Pick a format, Boxed Lunches for individual portions, or Subs by the Box (the party tray option) for group-style sharing.

Choose your subs. For boxed lunches, this usually means collecting individual preferences ahead of time. For Subs by the Box, pick a spread that covers different tastes, a mix from the Cold Subs menu is the standard approach.

Add extras, chips, cookies or brownies, and drinks, since these usually aren't bundled in automatically.

Place the order through the Jersey Mike's app, online catering portal, or by calling your local store directly, ideally at least 24 hours ahead for anything beyond a small order. Ordering direct rather than through a delivery marketplace also means the order earns Shore Points toward your account, something a third-party delivery app order won't do.

Planning for Dietary Needs

Vegetarians have one clear option: The Veggie, built with provolone, swiss, and green bell peppers. There's no vegan sub on the menu. For gluten sensitivity, a gluten-free roll is available at some locations for boxed lunches, but it's not universal, confirm with your store ahead of time rather than assuming. If your group includes someone with a serious gluten restriction, ordering their sub as Sub in a Tub instead removes the guesswork entirely, no roll to double-check.

Large recurring catering accounts are one of the reasons Jersey Mike's locations sometimes staff up around office parks and event venues; if that side of the business interests you, our pages on working at Jersey Mike's and what it costs to open a franchise cover the operational side of the brand.

Catering FAQ

What catering options does Jersey Mike's offer?

Two main formats: Boxed Lunches, an individually packaged sub, chips, and a cookie per person, and Subs by the Box, whole sandwiches cut into pieces for sharing across a group, sometimes called a party tray.

Does Jersey Mike's have a party tray?

Yes, though Jersey Mike's own menu calls it Subs by the Box rather than a party tray. It's the same idea: whole subs sliced into pieces and arranged for a group to share, rather than individually packaged portions.

How much does Jersey Mike's catering cost?

Pricing varies significantly by location, format, and sub selection. Sources report per-person costs and flat box prices that don't always agree, so getting a quote for your specific order and location is the only reliable way to know the actual cost.

How far in advance should I order catering?

24 hours ahead is the standard recommendation for larger orders, though many locations can accommodate same-day requests placed earlier in the day. Calling ahead is safer than assuming for anything time-sensitive.

Can I get hot subs for catering?

It depends on the location. Catering menus commonly default to cold subs, and whether hot subs are available for a catering order is worth confirming directly with your local store before you plan around it.

Does Jersey Mike's catering have gluten-free options?

Some locations offer a gluten-free roll for boxed lunches, though it's not universal. If you have guests with dietary restrictions, confirming availability ahead of time, or planning for Sub in a Tub as a bread-free option, is the safer approach.

This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Jersey Mike's Franchise Systems, Inc. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Pricing, serving sizes, and availability vary by location; confirm directly with your local store before placing a catering order.